Post by Admin on Nov 24, 2014 15:44:32 GMT
Attacks used: 47/60. 4 People booted for not participating. 5 only used one attack...
14 attacks lost...
I am going to review each members/elders attacks. No need to review coleaders and leaders...
#1. James - attacked enemies #6, 24. Earned 1 star. Both attacks lacked CC troops. One attack lacked spells.
Troops used: First attack (0 stars): 61 archer, 9 giants, 19 wall-breakers, 2 wizards, 2 healers, BK and AQ. 2 lightning and 2 rage spells (lvl 4 for both) NO CC troops
Second attack: (1 star) 28 archers, 9 giants, 7 wall-breakers, 22 wizards, 2 dragons. BK and AQ. NO SPELLS. NO CC troops.
I would give his war effort an F. I know both twisted and I have mentioned to him to make sure to have CC troops...
#2. Spanky Ham - attacked #7 and 8. Earned 3 new stars.
#3. Brendrew - attacked #6 and 8. Earned 3 stars.
#4. Oakfieldmark - attacked #4 and 9. Earned 3 stars.
#5. ||||||||||| - attacked #5 and 3. Earned 5 stars.
#6. robpost - 0 attacks used. Has been kicked.
#7. Darken - attacked #11 and 7. Earned 2 stars.
#8. Twisted47 - attacked #9 and 14. Earned 3 stars.
#9. Pack of wolves - attacked #10 and 13. Earned 5 stars. (was one wiz tower away from 6, stupid timer)
10. caitie - attacked #17 and 18. Earned 4 stars.
11. caconym - attacked #12 and 21. Earned 1 star. Seems low for him... not sure what happened.
12. Kum Fei - attacked #15 and 16. Earned 5 stars.
13. Goblin Army - attacked #19 and 20. Earned 5 stars.
14. joanne - attacked #27 and 30. Earned 5 stars - IF her two attacks had come towards the end of the war and was working to clean up the bottom and get some stars these attacks would be acceptable. However her attacks were the 3rd and 8th from our clan. IF I recall right she has been talked to about this type of behavior right? I would grade this as a D.
15. MozambiqueFox - attacked #26. Earned 0 stars
16. htom - kicked
17. Lucy - attacked #25 and 29. Earned 1 stars
18. 17 Spear - attacked #26 and 29. Earned 0.
19. mosab - kicked
20. RayMizuki - kicked
21. Chocon0507 - attacked #23 and 26. Earned 2.
22. sikko87 - attacked #21 and 22. Earned 2
23. dr&d0n - attacked #28 and 29. Earned 2
24. B-root - attacked #26 and 29. Earned 0
25. Dragon 11 - attacked #29. Earned 0
26. Michael - attacked #28 and 30. Earned 0
27. whoever - attacked #26 and 29. Earned 2
28. javier the merc - attacked #24. Earned 0
29. Saif Alloze - attacked #22. Earned 0
30. Kahl - attacked #29. Earned 0
(will be editing the above as I can and have time to review attacks (I do have real work to do)
So a quick recap/breakdown by the top 10, middle 10 and bottom 10.
Top 10 : 29 stars
Middle 10: 17 stars
Bottom 10: 8 stars (6 of the 10 failed to get a star)
14 attacks lost...
I am going to review each members/elders attacks. No need to review coleaders and leaders...
#1. James - attacked enemies #6, 24. Earned 1 star. Both attacks lacked CC troops. One attack lacked spells.
Troops used: First attack (0 stars): 61 archer, 9 giants, 19 wall-breakers, 2 wizards, 2 healers, BK and AQ. 2 lightning and 2 rage spells (lvl 4 for both) NO CC troops
Second attack: (1 star) 28 archers, 9 giants, 7 wall-breakers, 22 wizards, 2 dragons. BK and AQ. NO SPELLS. NO CC troops.
I would give his war effort an F. I know both twisted and I have mentioned to him to make sure to have CC troops...
#2. Spanky Ham - attacked #7 and 8. Earned 3 new stars.
#3. Brendrew - attacked #6 and 8. Earned 3 stars.
#4. Oakfieldmark - attacked #4 and 9. Earned 3 stars.
#5. ||||||||||| - attacked #5 and 3. Earned 5 stars.
#6. robpost - 0 attacks used. Has been kicked.
#7. Darken - attacked #11 and 7. Earned 2 stars.
#8. Twisted47 - attacked #9 and 14. Earned 3 stars.
#9. Pack of wolves - attacked #10 and 13. Earned 5 stars. (was one wiz tower away from 6, stupid timer)
10. caitie - attacked #17 and 18. Earned 4 stars.
11. caconym - attacked #12 and 21. Earned 1 star. Seems low for him... not sure what happened.
12. Kum Fei - attacked #15 and 16. Earned 5 stars.
13. Goblin Army - attacked #19 and 20. Earned 5 stars.
14. joanne - attacked #27 and 30. Earned 5 stars - IF her two attacks had come towards the end of the war and was working to clean up the bottom and get some stars these attacks would be acceptable. However her attacks were the 3rd and 8th from our clan. IF I recall right she has been talked to about this type of behavior right? I would grade this as a D.
15. MozambiqueFox - attacked #26. Earned 0 stars
16. htom - kicked
17. Lucy - attacked #25 and 29. Earned 1 stars
18. 17 Spear - attacked #26 and 29. Earned 0.
19. mosab - kicked
20. RayMizuki - kicked
21. Chocon0507 - attacked #23 and 26. Earned 2.
22. sikko87 - attacked #21 and 22. Earned 2
23. dr&d0n - attacked #28 and 29. Earned 2
24. B-root - attacked #26 and 29. Earned 0
25. Dragon 11 - attacked #29. Earned 0
26. Michael - attacked #28 and 30. Earned 0
27. whoever - attacked #26 and 29. Earned 2
28. javier the merc - attacked #24. Earned 0
29. Saif Alloze - attacked #22. Earned 0
30. Kahl - attacked #29. Earned 0
(will be editing the above as I can and have time to review attacks (I do have real work to do)
So a quick recap/breakdown by the top 10, middle 10 and bottom 10.
Top 10 : 29 stars
Middle 10: 17 stars
Bottom 10: 8 stars (6 of the 10 failed to get a star)
